| |
Outcome Data from an In-Home Early
Intervention Program
for Children with Autism Younger than
3 Years Old
Paul D. Coyne, Ph.D., BCBA and
Katherine E. Calarco, M.A., BCBA
Coyne and Associates, Inc. Encinitas,
CA
Introduction
Past research has demonstrated that children with Autism and Autism Spectrum Disorders benefit from early intervention utilizing Applied Behavior Analysis techniques. Much of this research has primarily focused on children 3-4 years of age receiving between 10-40+ hours per week of intervention (Kasari, 2002). Thus far, research has not conclusively indicated how much early intervention is needed, or at what age services should begin. Outcome data were analyzed from an in-home early intervention program for children under 3 with Autism or PDD-NOS. Children entered the program at various points of time, received 12 hours per week of 1:1 intervention, and exited at age 3. Outcome data at program end representing cognitive, language, and social/emotional measures from the Bayley and the Brigance were compared across children grouped by program duration. Bayley data were analyzed controlling for mental retardation. Results were compared to children of the same age who had received no prior intervention.
Methods
Subjects: Children were selected for analysis based on age, testing data, and duration of program. “Control” children entered the program at 34-35 months of age and had no prior intervention. Children were separated into groups based on program duration
Bayley Participants: Two analyses were conducted on Bayley data: High MDI and Low MDI. The cut-off of MDI score ≥ 65 was used for the High MDI group to control for possible effects of mental retardation. The Low MDI group comprised all children in the program with MDI scores to < 50. Children were separated into groups based on program duration of 4 months.
Brigance Participants: 372 children comprised the Brigance group. Children were separated into groups based on program duration of 3 months. Language composite scores were created from the Brigance as follows:
- Receptive Composite: Receptive Colors, Receptive Body Parts, Receptive Vocabulary
- Expressive Composite: Expressive Colors, Expressive Body Parts, Expressive Vocabulary
Early Intervention Program: Children received 12 hours/week of home-based 1:1 intervention. The program implements both Discrete Trial and Pivotal Response Teaching techniques. Interventionists have either their BA or MA.
Analyses: Scores from the Bayley were analyzed using univariate ANOVAs with program duration as the between-subjects factor and MDI as the within-subject factor. Pairwise comparisons, corrected for multiple comparisons, were utilized to assess group differences. Means of Brigance data were used and represented graphically.
- Post-test data was used for children who had received intervention for 2 or more months; pre-test data was used for children who entered the program at 34 months of age or later.
Results-Bayley
High MDI: At a mean age of 35 months, there was a significant effect of program duration on MDI score (F (3, 73) = 11.685, p = .000 ).
- Post-hoc tests revealed that children enrolled in the program 2-6, 6.1-10, and 10.1-14 months scored significantly higher compared to the control group (Figure 1 and Table 1).
- Children receiving intervention for 10.1-14 months scored significantly higher than children who received 2-6 and 6.1 to 10 months of services.
Low MDI: At a mean age of 35 months, there was a significant effect of program duration on MDI score (F (3, 80) = 5.470, p = .002 ).
- Post-hoc tests revealed that children enrolled in the program 2-6, 6.1-10, and 10.1-14 months scored significantly higher compared to the control group (Figure 2 and Table 1).

Figure 1. Mean Bayley MDI scores
as a function of length of intervention for program children
with MDIs ≥ 65.
*Controls < other groups, p < .05
** 2-6 months < 10.1-14 months,
p < .05
**6.1-10 months < 10.1-14 months,
p < .05
|

Figure 2. Mean Bayley MDI scores
as a function of length of intervention for program children
with MDIs to < 50.
*Controls < other groups, p < .05
|

Table 1. Bayley MDI scores and sample
sizes for the two Bayley analyses.
|
Results- Brigance
At a mean age of 35 months, age equivalent scores for children
receiving intervention were greater than those of controls.
Language: Both Receptive and Expressive Composite scores were greater
for children receiving intervention than for controls. Gains increased
as a function of program duration. Children receiving intervention
exhibited greater expressive than receptive composite scores, whereas
controls exhibited the reverse trend (Figure 3).
Social/Emotional: Social/Emotional scores were greater for children receiving intervention
than for controls. Gains increased as a function of program duration
(Figure 4).

Figure 3. Mean Brigance age equivalents
for Receptive and Expressive Composite scores as a function
of length of intervention program.
|

Figure 4. Mean Brigance age equivalents
for Social and Emotional skills as a function of length
of intervention program.
|
Conclusion
- Children with MDIs ≥ 65 receiving intervention scored significantly
higher on the Bayley compared to a control group; the longer a
child participated in the program the greater the gains.
- These effects remained after children with lower MDIs were included,
suggesting that the significant differences are a true effect of
intervention and are not accounted for by cognitive level.
-
Children
receiving intervention demonstrated greater language and social/emotional
skills than controls at 35 months of age. Expressive skills appears
to be the area of greatest gain.
-
These results indicate that early
intervention assists in the acquisition of skills and longer periods
of intervention are associated with greater gains. Additional outcome
studies are necessary to assess the effects of early intervention
programs for young children with Autism and what child-attributes
may contribute to gains made.
|